The Angels are coming off a decade of extraordinarily poor offense from their catchers.
From 2010-2019, Angels catchers had the fifth-worst wRC+ (81) in baseball. They ranked third-worst in both OBP (.292) and SLG (.359). Mike Napoli’s 26-home run output in 2010 was by far the most by any catcher in a season. Only two other catchers, Martin Maldonado and Chris Iannetta, reached double-digits. Enter, Jason Castro.
The Angels inked the 32-year-old backstop to a one-year $6.85 million deal this past offseason. Castro himself had six separate double-digit home run seasons this past decade and brings strong pitch framing. The Angels may be banking on more from Castro, however. Castro’s batted ball profile and Statcast profile changed in a major way last year. While he’s not an outspoken swing change propagandist a la Josh Donaldson or Justin Turner, his stats suggest he made major changes. Castro’s changed batted ball profile and new profound quality of contact make him a fascinating case study for 2020.
Jason Castro: Statcast Darling
The following chart shows Castro’s Statcast numbers and his MLB ranks among hitters with at least 250 plate appearances last year. A quick primer on some of these numbers that I used from Baseball Savant:
xwOBA and xwOBAcon are based on wOBA, or Weighted On-Base Average. wOBA is much better than batting average because it includes walks and properly values hits (not all hits are equal). xWOBA is simple: what is your expected wOBA based on your underlying stats? xWOBAcon, meanwhile, is looking solely at your xWOBA based on balls in play. Sweet-spot percentage measures any ball hit between 8-32 degrees, the optimal range for hard-hit baseballs. Barrel percentage measures how often you hit hard baseballs at an optimal launch angle.
|Average EV||91.5 mph||23rd|
By every measure, Castro was legitimately one of baseball’s best in terms of crushing baseballs. By solely looking at the quality of contact, Castro was a top-10 hitter, whether it is xwOBAcon, barrel percentage or sweet-spot percentage. Castro’s .498 xwOBAcon placed him right between Christian Yelich and Ronald Acuña Jr, who happen to be two pretty good hitters. Castro popped 13 home runs in just 275 plate appearances, averaging 415 feet on each dinger. Unsurprisingly, Castro’s fly-ball percentage shot up to a career-high 39.3 percent.
He always hit for reasonable power but this quality of contact came out of nowhere.
|Career (Statcast era)||.316||.408||87.5 MPH||37.7%||9.1%|
Castro made meaningful changes that you can’t fake. It’s one thing to BABIP your way to a flukey year or get lucky on your HR/FB rate. It’s another thing to make changes this significant without real and skillful changes. Castro hasn’t been super vocal about his swing changes but he is a pupil of Craig Wallenbrock. One of the most prominent hitting coaches in the baseball world, Wallenbrock has allegedly been working with Castro since at least 2014. Wallenbrock’s philosophy of hitting baseballs in the air runs counter to traditional “swing down on the ball” mantra. Other recipients of Wallenbrock’s teachings include Ryan Braun and J.D. Martinez, the latter who is one of the most prominent and outspoken swing changers. It’s possible that 2019 represented the fruition of all these changes and we can continue to expect more of this.
What to expect from Castro this year
Castro’s breakout was untimely on a personal level as his former team, the Twins, also had another catcher break out with massive power. Mitch Garver, similarly to Castro, made huge changes that resulted in him producing as baseball’s best offensive catcher. This limited Castro to just 79 games, a number he should clear with ease this season. Angels manager Joe Maddon has already said that Castro should play more than 100 games. If he can do that, he may be able to put his new changes into practice even more.
Castro is not without his risks, as he will be 33 years old in June and is two years removed from major knee surgery. Castro’s swing-and-miss issues (career 27.9 strikeout percentage) will also limit his overall offensive value. Still, this is a catcher capable of posting a league-average or better batting line who is also one of the better pitch framers in baseball. The ceiling may even be higher if last year’s changes were legit. If Castro maintains his positive changes from last year and manages to play 100+ games, he could theoretically approach a 3-win season.
Much of the offseason’s attention was focused on the signing of superstar Anthony Rendon and the pitching additions, or lack thereof. Don’t sleep on Jason Castro, though. He may be one the sneakiest free-agent additions from this past winter and gives the Angels a potentially deep─and devastating─lineup.
Photo credit: Travis Smith (UPI)
I am very hopeful that Castro can be a major force in the Angel’s lineup. One thing I would add is that the knee surgery he underwent a couple of years ago linked in the article will definitely help his longevity (especially this year) because the doctors were able to repair the meniscus and not take out more. This will give him more cushion to the knee joint and reduce the amount of wear on the cartilage allowing him to catch more than he did last year and hopefully put up those big numbers that Brent point out are possible.
Excellent point, I didn’t even think of that. Welcome to the site!
Interesting! I did not know that. Thanks for the info and for reading.
A big reason I was a big fan of signing Castro this winter. Don’t think he’ll be a superstar like Grandal, Realmuto, or, apparently, Garver, but I think he’ll be a league-average to above-average bat (which is pretty significant at the catcher position) who can pop off 20-25 bombs in 115 or so games with good pitch framing. That would be a massive upgrade.
I’d be drooling at that power output, for sure!
I think there’s an outside shot he finds himself as a top-5 catcher by WAR. He has the new power and the opportunity to make it happen.
Articles like this are why I love this site.
Or, well, why I’m starting to love it. The relationship is a little new to say I love it already. Although it feels familiar – kind of like dumping someone and dating their twin instead.
I’m dying at this example 😆 thanks for reading!
Welcome to CtPG!
This is very exciting. I knew Castro could hit but this opens my eyes. Salivating over the 2020 lineup.
Castro hitting 7/8 in the lineup adds the depth that this lineup hasn’t had in quite some time.
I long for the days of the Napoli backstop. It’s too bad that Mike Scioscia never really utilized him to the fullest, much to the detriment of the team. At least Castro will be an improvement over Max I-can’t-hit-worth-a-shit Stassi.
I was hoping the Mike Scioscia underutilized Napoli meme would stay at HalosHeaven. Look back at his career and show me where he could have had significantly more playing time. Factor in his injury history, e.g., his left hip labrum tear which goes back to his Angel days:
“Prior to signing with the Red Sox, Napoli did have pain from a labrum tear in his left hip that he’s had since his time with the Angels, and it was the investigation of that issue which led to his diagnosis of AVN. When Napoli was catching, the labrum was an issue, and the pinch he felt while moving quickly in and out of a squat was a constant reminder. “When I caught, it would rub and it’d be pinching so bad that the whole side of my leg would be hurting,” he said. That pain was managed with cortisone shots throughout his time in Texas, but once Napoli stopped catching, the pain went away.”
There’s a lot of opinions rendered without knowing all the behind the scenes information – it could be argued Sosh actually maximized his playing time, given this knowledge.
You know, when I saw that Castro improved significantly in 2019 on offense, I figured it was close enough to the trend not to investigate. Man, I was wrong. Nice find and deep dive, Brent!
Castro and Stassi will be a productive duo this year and make middling pitchers look impressive.
I like your optimism. I would say you’re possibly half right.
Thanks, Rahul! I’m stoked to see what Castro can do with more playing time with the new changes.