If I Were The Angels GM (Charles Sutton)

Welcome to our annual off season series where we get to pretend to run the franchise and fill out the following season’s roster. Unlike in recent years, we have no idea who will run the team, so the title has changed.

Rules:

Yes, there are rules and let’s go over them now. First off, in looking at the Angels recent payroll but allowing for a small Kroenke bonus, we will set payroll at $210 million. Spotrac currently projects the Angels to have $117 million in payroll but that is missing the Anthony Rendon payout. So, for this exercise the Angels have $125 million on the books and you have $85 million to spend before non tenders.

You must use salaries from either MLBTR’s projections or from FanGraphs projections when available. If not, be realistic when signing players outside of the Top 50.

Use the estimated salaries from MLBTR when non tendering players.

Trades must be run through baseballtradevalues.com or taken from there to show they are fair and realistic. If you need one run for you, please reach out to me and I will try to run it for you.

Where are the Angels bleeding wins?

PlayerPosition2026 bWAR
Sam AldegheriLHP starter-0.2
Sam BachmanRHP reliever-0.3
Caden DanaRHP starter??? (-0.9 for career)
Reid DetmersLHP starter+4.2
Mitch FarrisLHP starter+0.4
Jose FerminRHP reliever+0.3
Ryan JohnsonRHP starter0.0
Ben JoyceRHP reliever0.0
Brett KerryRHP starter+0.2
Yusei KikuchiLHP starter+0.4
George KlassenRHP starter+0.4
Jack KochanowiczRHP starter-0.8
Trevor MartinRHP reliever-0.4
Luke MurphyRHP starter-0.5
Samy Natera, Jr.LHP starter+0.8
Grayson RodriguezRHP starter-1.0
Tayler SaucedoLHP reliever+0.8
Walbert UrenaRHP starter+3.8
Ryan WatsonRHP reliever+0.5
Blake WeimanRHP starter+0.3
Tyler HeinemanCatcher-0.7
Logan PorterCatcher+0.1
Nacho Alvarez, Jr.SS+0.3
Vaughn GrissomUtil+0.2
Denzer Guzman3B/SS-0.7
Christian Moore2B-1.3
Zach NetoSS+5.3
Oswald PerazaUtil+1.3
Nolan Schanuel1B+2.1
Moises BallesterosDH-0.8
Gustavo CamperoOF+0.1
Josh LoweOF+0.1
Wade MecklerOF+2.4
Jose SiriOF+0.7
Bryce TeodosioOF0.0
Mike TroutOF+4.1

The Angels also selected the contract of Nicolo Pinazzi, a left-handed reliever, on October 30, 2026. We have no data on him. We’ll see about him in spring training I guess. I have to endure Tyler Heineman since the Angels have a one-year, $1,237,500 deal with him now. $83,762,500 Million is left to spend after that transaction.

The other negative WAR guys are on the hot seat. Getting replacement level guys instead of them would be a net gain of 6 wins. I am obviously going to want better than replacement level guys since 68-94 is not a very sexy record to shoot for. If I non-tender Sam Bachman, Josh Lowe, and Grayson Rodriguez I then have $90,562,500 to spend seeking another 14 WAR and a .500 record on paper. $6,468,750 Million per WAR is a tight squeeze but not completely ridiculous. A .500 record would be relatively studly in the AL West. The arbitration raises of the arb guys I kept come to $4.27 Million over what they made last year. I think this number may have been taken out before the $85 Million but I will leave some space in the budget.

Do any of the negative WAR players have trade value?

Sam Aldegheri0.00
Caden Dana0.00
Jack Kochanowicz0.00
Trevor Martin2.3
Luke Murphy1.2
Denzer Guzman1.9
Moises Ballesteros21.7
Christian Moore15.5

Whether there is a market inefficiency to be exploited here depends on whether bWAR and the Trade Simulator mean anything. We can see that there is some chaff on this table, but some of the under performers have intriguing trade values. I listed the intermediate trade value figure for each.

The Trades

Denzer Guzman to the Marlins for Calvin Faucher. Faucher put up +0.5 WAR in 2026 so this is a net swing to the positive of 1.2 WAR and makes Trevor Martin tradeable. Faucher’s projected arbitration salary is $2.9 Million which is an increase of $2.14 Million over what Guzman is making.

Moises Ballesteros to the Nationals for CJ Abrams. Abrams put up 5.1 WAR in 2026 so this is a net positive swing of 5.9 WAR. It solves second base and makes Christian Moore demoteable. Abrams is projected to get $4.2 Million in arbitration which is $3,412,500 over what Ballesteros is making.

$85,010,000 remains available and I have added 7.1 WAR in trades. I still need a third baseman, a center fielder, and a designated hitter. A few depth starters would be nice in case Dana, Aldegheri, and Kochanowicz never get it together.

Free Agent Acquisitions

3B J.P. Crawford 2 years @ $16M, $8M AAV, 0.9 WAR in 2026

DH Tyler Stephenson 2 years @ $15M, $7.5M AAV, 2.5 WAR in 2026

C Carson Kelly 2 years @ $20M, $10M AAV, 1.9 WAR in 2026

CF Luis Robert, Jr. 1 year @ $14M, $14M AAV, 1.0 WAR in 2026

LHSP Robbie Ray 1 year @ $12M, $12M AAV, 2.3 WAR in 2026

RHSP Paul Blackburn 2 year @ $15M, $7.5M AAV, 3.1 WAR in 2026

This totals $66.5 Million for a total of 11.7 WAR from free agents. If I subtract this money and the arbitration raises from my $85,010,000 I have $14,240,000 burning a hole in my pocket. Who do you think I should go after?

26 Man Roster

LHSP Detmers, RHSP Urena, LHSP Ray, RHSP Blackburn, LHSP Kikuchi with RH Klassen and LH Farris for long relief.

DH Tyler Stephenson

C Carson Kelly

C Tyler Heineman

1B Nolan Schanuel

2B CJ Abrams

SS Zach Neto

3B J.P. Crawford

LF Mike Trout

CF Luis Robert, Jr.

RF Wade Meckler

Util Oswald Peraza

4th OF Jose Siri

LHRP Tayler Saucedo

RHRP Ben Joyce

RHRP Ryan Watson

LHRP Samy Natera, Jr.

LHRP Blake Weiman

RHRP Brett Kerry

RHRP Calvin Faucher

I might have called Carson Kelly the DH but Stephenson’s defense is not so good.

Those who have options

Of those I didn’t trade or put on my 26 man, the following are already in the minors: Aldegheri, Pinazzi, Martin, Porter, Alvarez, Jr., Campero.

Of those I didn’t trade, non-tender, put on my 26 man, or are already in the minors the following have options: Dana, Johnson, Murphy, Teodosio. That brings us to 36. Four spots remain on the 40 man roster. Let’s see if any of those other negative WAR guys with no options can make it through waivers. Who I would protect from Rule 5 is a whole ‘nother article. This article is already long.

Thanks for reading!

Subscribe
Notify of
8 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
red floyd
Legend
35 minutes ago

So my birthday present was Pinazzi. We’ll have to see how that goes.


Pineapple12
Legend
56 minutes ago

Mo Baller for Abrams would require a full investigation. Other than that, really nice job!

cookmeister
Trusted Member
1 hour ago

No chance the Nats do that.

I like the approach, though. “Replacing” negative WAR guys with others on the surface is a solid idea.

GonFishin
Trusted Member
2 hours ago

To the author, do you plan on trading Bremmer/Arjun/or Gridlinger? Maybe 2 of them? Because that is the only way you even get the conversation started for CJ Abrams. They turned down massive bids for him at TDL so Mo Baller is likely the 3rd or 4th best in any deal for him, certainly not a headliner piece.

Like the ideas of JP, Kelly, Robert, and some bullpen arms. Not sure what the new front office’s plan will be, but at minimum, they need a catcher, middle infielder, OF, and 2-3 bullpen arms. That’s just to be respectable.

Jeff Joiner
Editor
Legend
2 hours ago

Take that remaining $14 million and buy some relief arms. Bring back Brock Burke for half and maybe a JoJo Romero and the bullpen looks a ton better.

gitchogritchoffmypettis
Legend
2 minutes ago
Reply to  Charles Sutton

I’ll do one if I ever leave work before the season starts.

8
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x