Okay, I’ll play this game CTPG.
The Rally Monkey I bought during the 2002 playoff run is collecting dust in the back of my parents closet, the color is slowly fading, the eyes are losing their shine, my memory of the happiness it once brought me has all but faded from my mind. This is what it has felt like to be an Angles fan for the past 10 years. But, what is this now?! Arte is gone? Smart deadline deals that give us some hope of a future? I am ready to reengage (and spend money, KSE) with the team I used to love. I am actually excited about the next couple of years.
So, if Stan is interested, yes I will be the next GM and this is what I would do.
I’ll use rules just like the other pretend GMs on this site:
- $210m salary cap
- No other rules, I am just a fan not a reporter.
The Goal:
Use what we have, to get what we want.
What do we want? A good baseball team. Not just a flashy signing or a fire sale that creates hope in the next decade. A good team with a plan for the future.
What do we have? An improving farm system with players that could realistically fill needs in the next couple of years. Two home grown talents already producing top results. Big market money with growth potential if we start winning. Open positions that need to be filled while young players grow into big league roles.
Strategic Focus:
- Win some games in 2027 to build on the energy of the team sale
- Set the core, don’t speculate on Detmers and Neto
- Build the farm system and do not block developing players
- Don’t commit to high dollar long-term free agents until the farm has had time to prove itself
- Use money to fill roster gaps with mid-tier stable veterans with upside on short term deals
Set The Core:
Should the Angles trade away a 25-year-old shortstop who just produced a 5.3 WAR season for prospects who might someday be as good as Zach Neto. No.
Same logic for a home grown young starting pitcher? How many of the top 25 pitching prospects will be as good as Reid Detmers was in the second half of last year? Do you roll the dice? No.
I am keeping them. First move, extend Neto and Detmers and put their pictures on the front of the stadium next to Mike.
Neto probably gets seven years $150 million. For 2027 let’s say $14m.
Detmers gets six years $130m. Let’s say $15m in the first year.
Trades:
No trades. This is about understanding needs and building on what we have. Trades in 2028 or 2029 as needed.
Free Agents Strategy:
Do not f***ing sign Tarik Skubal. He is a really good pitcher and probably will be worth the money he is going to get, but he doesn’t hit for power, play right field, third base, second base, catcher, or hold down high leverage relief innings. The Angels are not one signing away from the division series. Do not sign any high AAV long term deals.
Instead target three types of players. Short-term rebound candidates, stable veteran bridges and relievers with legitimate upside. The Angels have two things going for them that they should exploit when recruiting players: they have money and they will have big league playing time available in 2027. As GM, I am going to pay a little more to get the right players on short term deals that are both flexible and attractive trade pieces.
A quality reliever might be able to get $9m to pitch the seventh inning on a contender, but come to Anaheim for $10m and you will get the opportunity to pitch in high leverage spots. If you are good and we are not, you will be pitching in October for someone else and our farm will get a little better.
The free agent money buys time for the new interesting prospects to develop and trade chips to turn into more prospects to fuel long term contention.
Free Agent Class:
Luis Robert Jr. – 1 year, $15m
This is the purest example of the strategy. A former 5 WAR guy coming off some injuries looking for a short term deal. Pay him a little extra, give him 500 at bats, everyday playing time (albeit mostly in right field) and have him hit in the middle of a line up. I bet he takes that to rebuild his value for next year’s free agency.
If he rebounds and the Angels are in the hunt, keep him.
If he rebounds and the Angels are bad, trade him.
If he fails, the contract is gone after a year and Rada, Alvarez, or Rodriguez step in at a fraction of the cost.
If Rada and Alvarez force their way in, trade Robert for the next wave.
This is what 2027 should be about at the Big A.
2027 salary: $15 million
Gleyber Torres – 2 years, $30m
Torres gives the Angels a stable second baseman without permanently blocking Christian Moore. Moore should play every day in Triple-A until he forces his way back. If he does, great. If he does not, the Angels are not giving away a major-league position while waiting.
Torres also fits the bridge idea because two years is short enough to preserve flexibility while still giving the player security.
2027 salary: $15 million.
Tyler Stephenson – 2 years, $20m
The Angels do not need a star catcher. They need stability.
Stephenson gives the team a competent everyday option while allowing Moisés Ballesteros to get regular at-bats without carrying the entire catching workload.
It also gives Jacob Cozart more time. If Cozart earns more playing time, the Angels can gradually shift the workload.
2027 salary: $10 million.
Mauricio Dubon – 2 Years, $20m
Dubón is exactly the kind of player this roster needs. He can cover second, third, shortstop and all three outfield positions. That matters on a roster evaluating multiple young players at once.
If Rada struggles, Dubón can cover center. If Denzer Guzman struggles, Dubón can play third. If Torres gets hurt, Dubón can play second. If Trout needs more DH time, Dubón can cover the outfield.
He fixes a lot of problems on a young team that is developing at different rates.
2027 salary: $10 million.
Evan Phillips – 2 years, $22m
The bullpen needs multiple legitimate late-inning options. Phillips has already succeeded in high-leverage situations and has the kind of rebound profile the Angels should target. He also gets something in Anaheim that a deeper contender may not guarantee: important innings.
2027 salary: $11 million.
Bryan Abreu – 2 years, $20m
Abreu’s 2026 season lowered his market value, but the strikeout ability remains and his second half was much stronger. This is another opportunity to buy upside. The Angels can offer him regular leverage work and a chance to re-establish himself.
2027 salary: $10 million.
A.J. Minter – 2 Years, $18m
We need another established left-handed reliever. Samy Natera Jr. was promising, but I do not want the bullpen dependent on everything going right with one young arm.
Minter gives the Angels another experienced late-inning option and another possible trade piece if the season goes badly.
2027 salary: $9 million.
The 2027 Roster
My lineup would be:
Nelson Rada — CF
Zach Neto — SS
Mike Trout — LF
Luis Robert Jr. — RF
Nolan Schanuel — 1B
Tyler Stephenson — C
Gleyber Torres — 2B
Moisés Ballesteros — DH
Denzer Guzman — 3B
The bench would be built around Mauricio Dubón, Wade Meckler, Vaughn Grissom and another internal outfielder.
Christian Moore starts in Triple-A. Jacob Cozart continues catching regularly. Raudi Rodriguez and Hayden Alvarez continue developing until they force the Angels to make room.
The Rotation
Don’t F***ing sign Tarik Skubal.
- Reid Detmers
- Walbert Ureña
- Yusei Kikuchi
- Grayson Rodriguez
- Ryan Johnson
The second best ERA in the back half of last year deserves time to prove itself. Don’t sign anyone, let them cook. The young guys need innings and if Bremner is ready it shouldn’t be hard to get him in the rotation. Figure out which young pitchers belong in the next competitive window before dropping a ton of cash on another arm.
The Bullpen
No true closer to start, let Ben Joyce earn it if he is going to. The high-leverage group should be Phillips, Abreu, Joyce, Minter, and Natera. With Fermin and some other young arms filling in the rest of the spots. Depth is key here. Lots of options rather than one single point of failure.
The Payroll
$80 Million on seven free-agents, plus Detmers and Neto extensions, and cutting some of the bottom end of the roster Opening Day payroll is roughly $202-205m. Comfortably under the $210m limit (you are welcome Stan).
How Good Is This Team?
Using WAR projections I know nothing about (CTPG staff feel free to actually do this work), I expect 83-86 wins. In the AL West that sells tickets.
There is downside risk. The young guys may be ready. The veterans may not rebound. So you sell at the deadline.
The upside, Rada establishes himself, Ballesteros hits, Robert comes back to form, the bullpen works out and the projection moves to the upper 80s in wins. That is a legit wildcard competitor in 2027.
That’s great! But, under my General Manager reign we are not building for 2027. 2027 is the bridge and if it goes badly we sell. Actually, if it doesn’t go exceptionally well, we sell. Remember the goal; use what we have to get what we want, a good baseball team.
Stan’s money bought us the following trade chips on short term high upside deals ready to flip to a contender:
Gleyber Torres
Mauricio Dubón
Evan Phillips
A.J. Minter
Bryan Abreu
Yusei Kikuchi
Tyler Stephenson
All of these guys have equivalents in the minors waiting to get a cup of coffee at the end of the year.
The Real Target Is 2028 & 2029
The roster should get younger and less expensive over the next two years. Bremer can replace Kikuchi, Arjun Nimmala can take 3rd (or short), Cozart can take catcher. Rodriguez or Alvarez can push out Roberts. Young promising pitchers can take their time seasoning in the minors to move into key roles as the bridge contracts roll off or are traded.
As the prospects replace the bridge players, the payroll falls, but the team could actually get better. That creates financial room to address the positions that the farm system does not have an answer for rather than committing long term money before the team finds out what it actually needs.
Why I like this more than a Full Rebuild
First, my mother will be happy that I might finally get that stupid stuffed monkey out of her closet.
Secondly, a full rebuild is a gamble that trading Neto and Detmers will return more than two players that can become as good as Neto and Detmers in the next 2-4 years. That is asking for a lot of trust from a fan base that just spent all last summer at the top of the bleachers with their shirts off.
Instead, I would win some games, get some fans in the seats, sell some Neto and Detmers jerseys and use the new owner’s money to buy attractive trade targets to fill the roster holes while we wait for the rest of the next youth wave to hit.
And to the new owners who’s money I am spending, 3m fans came to the stadium in every year from 2003 to 2019. The sooner we can prove to all those people who stopped coming to games (myself included) that we are on a new path, the sooner they will come back to the stadium.
Photo credit: Rex Fregosi