If JJ Was Angels GM Redux

Hey, if Apocalypse Now, one of the greatest films of all time can get a Redux, so can my off season piece. Why? Because there are so many directions this team could go. Plus, I have the super duper credentials that let me write as much as I want.

So, let’s recap the rules and feel free to revisit my previous piece which focused on the farm far more than it did the Angels 2027 roster. I have $85 million to spend, must run my trades through the simulator, and need to use either MLBTR’s or FanGraphs projections for free agents.

I will also keep Tyler Heineman on my roster. He signed for about $265,000 less than estimated so I have a little more change in my pocket.

My goal here is to compete in a weak AL West in 2027, add some talent to the farm when I can, but definitely lose no talent on the farm.

Non-tender Josh Lowe and Jose Siri

If you K over 30% of the time you need to go. Perhaps a guy can K that much and be such a great defender I would consider him, but Lowe was horrid defensively and Siri was meh. This nets me $5.9 million plus the Heineman savings so I now have $91.2 million to spend.

Side note, Vaughn Grissom and Logan Porter are also gone because I need some roster spots.

Trade Yusei Kikuchi to the Red Sox for Masataka Yoshida and Juan Valera

Let’s swap out Japanese guys who are coming off injury shortened seasons and fill needs on other teams. Kikuchi is back to full strength now and provides the Red Sox with reliable veteran innings in their 5th spot in the rotation. Yoshida is completely blocked on the grass and now at DH thanks to Jake Bauers signing with the Sox.

The Angels struck out way too many times and do not have a dedicated DH. Yoshida strikes out about 11% of the time and fills in the DH spot most days. Juan Valera has a ton of talent but just had TJ and will need to rehab most of this year. He’s already 21 so by the time he is really back to strength it will be 2028 and my studs on the farm will be making their way to MLB. Valera could be the ace or the closer on that team, or maybe he’s still hurt. But his talent is mouth watering and I am stoked to add him.

Oh, this move saves me $3 million so I am up to $94.2 million to spend.

Trade Nolan Schanuel to the Diamondbacks for Kayson Cunningham and Mitch Bratt

I love this trade too much to give it up. And once I trade Kikuchi I open a hole in the rotation. Bratt fills it as a young, cost controlled arm that is more command than stuff. But his WHIP in the minors is much better than his stuff would indicate it should be. Pitching has an art component to it and I’m banking on that here.

Cunningham is a ridiculous prospect land for the farm. By pure hit tool he might pass Advincula as the best pure hitting middle infielder on the farm, and Advincula just won the NCAA batting title. He’s probably not a shortstop but the kid rakes. We need 19 year olds who rake.

By moving Schanuel’s $3 million projected salary to a minimum wage guy I also shed $2.3 million in payroll, so I am up to $96.5 million to spend.

Trade Mitch Ferris to Boston for Jarren Duran

Really I want the Angels to wait for the Red Sox to non-tender Duran but I can not simply expect that to happen. In landing Duran I at least ensure the Angels outfield defense is legit with Trout in left and Meckler in right field where he excelled at the end of the year. The bounce back potential for Duran is huge and getting him surrounded by family and friends could be the best thing for him.

Mitch Farris is not going to make this roster and he probably won’t make Boston’s. But with Boston shopping Duran openly during the GM meetings every team knows they are desperate to shed his salary. Farris is better than letting him walk for nothing.

So that takes me down to $85 million to spend. I’m right back where I started from but I’ve added a middle of the order bat, my center fielder, and two toolsy prospects who will land in our top 10 prospects lists. Not bad, huh?

Sign J.P. Crawford 2 years $16 million

A very familiar signing around here for good reason. Crawford has killed the Angels for years and we desperately need a second baseman. For $8 million per season, Crawford can be the solid but not spectacular player who plays the keystone. Simply moving that position to league average would be a huge boost.

New budget: $77 million

Sign Nathaniel Lowe 1 year $7 million

Swapping out the Lowe who can not hit for the Lowe who can. Nathaniel plays first base and just put up a wRC+ of 107 while popping 17 dingers in 126 games last year. He’s a lefty who is best against right handed pitching, but most of the league is right handed.

I’m down to $70 million.

Sign Kaima Taira 3 years $42 million

I love this kid’s potential. Ideally the Angels have a 1-2 tandem of him and Detmers for a decade under this scenario. Huge stuff, experience in both the rotation and bullpen, and this projection will turn out to be way low. But my Lowe number might be a tad high.

Anyway, this adds a legitimate 26 year old talent to the Angels staff which is suddenly super young and super inexpensive.

That gets me down to $56 million. I need a third baseman, fourth outfielder, and a bullpen.

Sign Tyrone Taylor 1 year $5 million

A defensive stud who crushes left handed pitching and is a great locker room guy, Taylor’s skillset and low K rate fit exactly what this team needs while Nelson Rada and Raudi Rodriguez develop in AAA. This signing makes Mike Trout, who will be covering left, the worst defender on the grass which means the outfield defense is sick.

$51 million leaves me plenty of room.

Sign Alec Bohm 1 year $10 million

Underwhelming and obvious, Bohm brings a very solid low strikeout rate with subpar power and defense. But third base was an utter black hole on both sides of the ball last year and the lineup could use a high contact righty and FanGraphs projects him to produce a wRC+ of 107 next year. So I take yet another negative and turn it into a positive.

$41 million to go.

Sign Alex Vesia 2 years $16 million

The lefty is nails and perfectly comfortable in the 8th inning. I need one of those and will use this projection which will also be low.

$33 million still to spend.

Sign Bryan Abreu 1 year $8 million

Started 2026 horribly but found most of his velocity in the second half and pitched more like his normal self. I think this is another low projection, but I’ll use it. Even at MLBTR’s 2/22 I would sign him. Abreu is used to handling the 9th inning and gives Ben Joyce time to be injured and figure stuff out.

$25 million to go.

Sign Jonathan Loasigia 1 year $6 million

When he’s healthy he’s really good and he was healthy last year. Will he be healthy next year? I’m not sure but for $6 million I will take the risk. Jonathan is a solid option for medium leverage spots. He’s the guy who gets the ball to the guy who closes out tight games.

Sign Brock Burke 1 year $5 million

Never should have traded him. This gives me three lefties with Vesia and Samy Natera Jr. in the fold. Between Burke and Loasigia I expect to be able to handle the medium leverage situations just fine and my manger has solid options to play match up baseball all night.

This gets me down to $14 million

Sign Maurico Dubon 2 years $20 million

Dubon is drastically better than anybody on our bench. And with Bohm and Crawford both on the wrong side of 30, Dubon gives me a quality backup for them and the ability to give Neto a day or so a week at DH to stay fresh. Another great thing about Dubon, he rarely strikes out. Plus glove, low K rate, and positional versatility are three things the Angels desperately need.

I’ll let Kroenke keep the extra $4 million although in real life I would greatly prefer it go to Austin Hedges or Kyle Higoshioka.

So here’s where we are:

Lineup vs. righties:

Meckler – RF

Trout – LF

Yoshida – DH

Neto – SS

Lowe – 1B

Crawford – 2B

Ballesteros – C

Duran – CF

Bohm – 3B

That is pretty sick now let’s take a look at lineup vs. lefties:

Taylor – RF

Trout – LF

Neto – SS

Bohm – 1B

Crawford – DH

Dubon – 3B

Duran – CF

Heineman – C

Peraza – 2B

Rotation:

Reid Detmers

Walbert Urena

Kaira Taima

Mitch Bratt

Ryan Johnson

AAA depth: George Klassen, Grayson Rodriguez, Caden Dana, Sam Aldegheri, and at some point Silent C.

Bullpen:

Bryan Abreu

Alex Vesia

Jonathan Loasigia

Brock Burke

Samy Natera Jr.

Trevor Martin

Sam Bachman

Jose Fermin

Bench: Dubon, Oswald Peraza, Tyrone Taylor, Tyler Heineman

Added to the farm: Cunningham is a wicked bat and Valera could be an ace, a closer, or a kid who blows out his elbow again. All I know is both have a couple of great tools, both are rated highly, and both slot in perfectly with last year’s draft class of college studs.

I think this lineup is decent enough to get some leads. I probably axed 200 to 300 strikeouts from the lineup, kept Detmers at the top of the rotation, and stacked the bullpen. When Ben Joyce is back healthy again he will knock the worst performing of the last four guys back to AAA.

How do you like this version?

Subscribe
Notify of
3 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Aww_Yeah
Member
19 minutes ago

Oh no, this is the “JJ pulls off his mask Scooby-Doo style and it was old-man-Arte all along!”
Keeping all his valuable trade chips and “adding to our core to bump us into contention” again!
Noooo!

Biggiswrth
Trusted Member
1 hour ago

Ben Joyce location? Not in your bullpen. I like where this was going. This is the I don’t trade my two boys version of JJ.

3
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x